Just can’t get the notification email to come “from” the person who filled in the form. I’ve checked, double-checked and triple-checked my settings and it still always comes from “me” so when I hit reply…it comes back to my email address. I’ve attached a screenshot of my form notification settings.
Now…the ONLY thing that I think could be stopping this is another plugin I use called Postman SMTP – https://postmansmtp.com/ so could that be fudging the problem here and stopping it from working?
A lot of servers doesn’t allow the “from” spoofing. (with SPF / DKIM / DMARC). So emails are silently rejected, the only option is to put the address in “reply-to” and put an allowed address (by the SMTP) in the form field.